I know there are god knows how many discussions on the Deathly Hallows already, but that's the movie, and this is for the Hallows themselves...
So this was my favourite scene in the movie, I love the sinister animation (the guy who did it has been optioned for a new version of Peter Pan...). If you haven't seen it, you can watch the story here:
Anyways, the question is:
Which Hallow would you choose - Elder Wand, Invisibility Cloak or Resurrection Stone - and why? (:
I know there are god knows how many discussions on the Deathly Hallows already, but that's the movie, and this is for the Hallows themselves...
So this was my favourite scene in the movie, I love the sinister animation (the guy who did it has been optioned for a new version of Peter Pan...). If you haven't seen it, you can watch the story here:
Anyways, the question is:
Which Hallow would you choose - Elder Wand, Invisibility Cloak or Resurrection Stone - and why? (:
Deffenetly the cloak for me. It seemsike it would be the most useful. I loved the animation sooo much!!! It was probably my favorite scene of the whole movie.
I think most people would choose the cloak because it's the most useful and long-lasting... nobody wants the stone because if they have lost someone, they wouldn't want to bring back just a shadow of them because it wouldn't be the same or fair to them. Less people seem to want the wand, because even though it's powerful and all, you would have to be really careful about it.
I forgot to say what I'd pick... the cloak, duh :)
elder wand
invisibility cloak :D
invisibility cloak definetly (:
i find it really interesting how no-one seems to want the resurrection stone, do you reckon if JK hadn't made it seem so 'bad' (can't think of the word) people would choose it?
I thought they explained this really well in the movie. I would probs have to go with invisibility cloak. Just so I could sneak round everywhere without being seen. :)
Yeah, definately the invisibility cloak :)
Seems like fun :D
Invisibility cloak!!!!! i think its smart to pick that one b/c it protected the man from death so i would pick that one! :)
Invisibility cloak! I've always wanted to be invisible! lol
@Music Is My Life
I know it is, I got the book when it came out... I was talking about how it was represented in the film.
This was in her book The Tales of Beedle the Bard, that's why when I listened to it, the story sounded familiar, check out the book if you haven't already.
Elder Wand me thinks.
I have 2 go with the cloak
!!!!
Probably the cloak. Although the stone would nice, if there were no complications & if it didn't end badly...Nah, the cloak. It'd be geat to sneak around Hogwarts, lol.
The Cloak.
And for some reason when they did this scene it reminded me of the movie Coraline.
just love hp full stop man, going to watch it for the fourth time tomorrow cant wait. P.s. id pick the cloak as usual
invisibility cloak! daeth wont find me!
I'll go for the Elder Wand, just to be original.
Think of how jealous everybody would be. >:D
yeah probably invisibility cloak too ! it could come in handy in tricky situations
I know it can sound a little bit monotonous, but i choose Invisibility Cloak.
And, by the way, i love all these HP topic ^.^
Invisibility cloak. Walking around with no one being able to see you seems so cool. Imagine the things you could get up too ;)
Invisibility Cloak :D Then I could totally stalk All Time Low ;)
@Matt
It did seem very Tim Burton
invisibility clock, definatley.
the idea of wondering around without anyone being able to see me is very appealing.
Invisibilty cloak.
I'm unbelievably nosey.
I'd have a total rave with that. ;D
Invisibility Cloak!
Imagine the fun you can have sneaking around :D!
The way the animation was done reminded me very much of Tim Burton.